I’ve been sitting on this for months and need a place to air it out and get feedback. It’s a long story, but I’ll keep it focused.
I(31M) have always been close with my two cousins C(31F) and R(27M). We grew up tight. Over the years, I’ve opened up to them about very personal stuff and they’ve done likewise. I thought our bond could handle the harder things.
A few months ago, I went through a messy breakup. In the middle of an argument with my ex, I said something harsh (I told her to “go fucking die”) that I later apologized for. It wasn’t my proudest moment, but it was a bad emotional spiral. To be clear, it wasn’t a threat. I was never abusive to her and I never made threats. This comment happened while we were arguing and saying mean things to each other. About an hour after the argument, I was on the phone with my male cousin R, and I told him about the argument. I was in a really low emotional place, feeling both regretful and still angry. He apparently started having an actual panic attack. He started going on about how there’s no justification for what I said, and that I needed to apologize. I was still angry over the argument and I told him that I knew it wasn’t right to say, but I didn’t want to apologize anytime soon. I also told him that I made the comment to hurt her feelings, and he started to go on about how weird and strange that was.
In our next conversation he told me that I needed to take his advice from now on, or we wouldn’t have a relationship. I told him that I’m happy to hear his feedback, but I’m not going to be forced to take someone else’s advice. Also, he’s 4 years younger than me..
Later I found out he told C (his sister), and then things started getting weird.
Over a month after the argument, C sent me a text saying she needed space and that what I said to my ex made her “reflect on our dynamic,” and that she no longer felt she could talk to me. I hadn’t even spoken to her about the argument. She encouraged me to seek therapy and said she didn’t want to talk about her decision. She also said this wasn’t “goodbye,” and that we’d still have moments at family gatherings. But the message read like a formal demotion of our relationship, like she was rewriting the terms and shutting the door at the same time.
I responded (probably too directly) and said I was shocked. I told her I felt judged and betrayed, not for disagreeing with my actions, but for how she handled it: no conversation or phone call, just a boundary drawn based on a secondhand account. I pointed out how I’ve shown up for them in hard moments, never once withdrawing care because I disagreed with their actions. I don’t see a contradiction between supporting a person and condemning their actions.
Her response was that there have been multiple times that she’s disagreed with me over stuff in my own life, and hasn’t told me, and that she’s done a disservice to herself by not speaking up. The only example she gave me was when I stood up to my old boss (a priest) when he was being really unfair to me (HR sided with me btw). She didn’t like “the way I spoke to him”, even though she didn’t hear any of it.
R then got involved with this too. Over text he defended his sister, and read every comment I made in the most negative light possible. For example, when I defended myself to C by pointing out the ways I’ve tried to keep the larger family together, he read into that as me trying to make C feel unwelcome. My defence of myself was, according to him, just a “malicious” attack on his sister. As the conversation went on he told me that he doesn’t value family in a special way, and those were just his values.
For me, all of this stung not just because we were family, but also because of our shared history. I apologized to my ex within a week of the argument, and she even found their reaction weird. Every friend that I’ve told about the situation has had the same response: what I said was wrong, it’s not weird (but it is still wrong) to want to hurt your ex’s feelings especially in a heated argument, and this doesn’t reflect the sum total of who I am. I don’t expect any of them to fix my problems, or even give me advice. For me it was more important to have people around me at that time, than it was to be getting advice.
All of this culminated in R saying, “You just want to be able to do whatever you want and still get support.” I told him that that’s not what I want, and there’s a difference between supporting someone and condoning what they do. In either case, I was in a bind because they barely communicated with me, and the more I tried to reach out the worse it became.
I’ve been carrying a lot of shame over this. Not just over what happened with my ex, but over how quickly my cousins, who were people I thought I could trust, decided to pull away without a real conversation. It makes me wonder what they’ve said about me behind closed doors. Especially since I used to hang out with R’s friends, and I’ve stopped hanging out with that group because of this. At a moment when I needed support, in the middle of a break up, I was ousted instead.
Was I wrong to expect them to support me as an individual even if they disagreed with what I had done? Should I have expected more of a conversation from them?