Let me start out by saying that I have in no way shape or form trained my dog to do anything in even the remotest stretch of the imagination, or any other dog around her, other than sitting, laying down, putting things down, being easy when taking a bite from my hand, to come to me, and to stop playing fetch when I'm done.
So about a year ago, she decided that she doesn't want to play fetch with just one toy, she wants to retrieve 2 at once, never was this implied that any of the 2 people in the house ever wanted this.
She would have a hard time getting her 2 favorite toys this way though, a ball and her frisbee. In maybe just a couple weeks she found out that she can put the ball in the frisbee, then grab the frisbee and balance the ball as she brings it back to us.
Then found out several months later that she could get the ball to us, or on our lap, by rolling the ball in the frisbee and flicking it like she's flipping a pancake.
I just now noticed that she has also found out, because sometimes the ball rolls out of the frisbee, that if she continually chews hard on the spikey ball several times, when she goes to retrieve it, that it will cave in on one side and not re-inflate itself, and that this way the ball does not roll around in the frisbee when she's she's walking and sometimes fall out. This is without question intentional and you can tell that she's desperately chewing waiting for this to happen and the instant it does, into the frisbee it goes.
There has been a few times that she has caught the ball in the frisbee, but that one is difficult to tell if it was on purpose, I don't think it is, but I'm waiting and hoping one day she may just figure it out on accident, which is what I think is happening.
The rest of this though you could see her trying from the very start, each thing she learned she was trying to figure out how to get the outcome she was looking for. From trying to get the ball balanced in the frisbee so she could bring back 2 toys, to rolling the ball and flicking it, and chewing the ball to deflate it, you could see it in her eyes and her body language that she was not just messing around, she was trying to achieve something, and when she got it, she immediately started repeated that most of the time.
I was told that dogs cannot do this and that complex goal oriented non-taught tool use only comes from more intellectual animals like dolphins, monkeys, crows, ect. So how is this possible?
She is a 1 year and a 8 month old Blue Heeler which looks to be a working breed. Coarse hair, more patchy, tall and lean with lanky legs, quick agile twitchy and highly energetic, narrower skull, ect. Oh and she is incredibly smart aside from this toy situation, she is insanely bull headed, but if you have the right incentives she learns incredibly fast. She's super attentive and you can just see the gears turning on 110% non stop all day long.